Monday 06/17/2019 by phishnet

ROO2 RECAP: NEVER MISS A BONNAROO CLOSING SHOW

[Recap/review of last night's Bonnaroo show is courtesy of Michael Ayers, user @yhgtbfkm. Note that there was no recap/review posted to the blog about Roo1's show, because no one attending the show volunteered to recap it, and there wasn't a webcast of it either, and we decided not to recap it based simply on the LivePhish recording. -Ed.]

Ahh, Bonnaroo. The perennial jam band festival that’s not really a jam band festival anymore.

I’ve had the pleasure of only attending Bonnaroo once, back in 2005. I saw a slew of amazing sets that weekend, including Benevento Russo Duo with Mike Gordon (a show you should definitely check out if you haven’t), Keller Williams, Jurassic 5 and Dave Matthews Band (laugh all you want, it was my first time seeing them and I really enjoyed it). That’s the nice part about festivals like this, it gives you the opportunity to see acts in the same place that you normally wouldn’t.

After the St Louis shows, I texted a good friend of mine who was on the fence about driving up to Camden to see them. I said, “Dude, I might be biased, but they are already playing lights out. You can’t miss seeing them in Camden.” I thought both nights in St Louis were spectacular. I will admit, the second night in particular will always be near and dear to my heart because of what transpired during the setbreak and how set two started out. I felt like there was little rust in the St. Louis shows (which you sometimes can’t say for tour openers), which made me both excited for the two nights at Bonnaroo and disappointed that I was not attending them.

So what will the boys have in store for us for Sunday down in Manchester? Will they bust out something they haven’t played in years (looking at you, "Free Bird")? Will Bo Bice and Trey share the stage again? (Spoiler alert: they did not, thank god.) Everyone is familiar with the old adage “Never Miss A Sunday Show,” would that apply to tonight as well? Let’s find out.

© 2019 Phish (courtesy of @AliveCoverage and @Phish_FTR)
© 2019 Phish (courtesy of @AliveCoverage and @Phish_FTR)

The band comes out on stage just a touch after 8:30pm CST and Trey, looking like he just stepped off of a yacht, starts us off with “Set Your Soul Free.” Right away, the band is locked in, with Trey shining in particular. Next up is “Blaze On,” allowing Page to strut his stuff on the keys. The song gently rolls into a beautiful jam before picking up steam to finish us off. Trey steps up to the mic and informs the crowd that he’s gonna slow it down so everyone can catch their breath and get the message. My heart briefly skips a beat as I think they’re about to play “Icculus," but instead Trey kicks off “Death Don’t Hurt Very Long.” I was fortunate to see the Kasvot Vaxt set in Vegas, and I’m glad to see these songs continue to be in the rotation.

1.0 makes its first appearance next, and it’s the song that got me into Phish, "Reba" (11/27/98 to be exact). It's excellent, with a solid composed section and a wonderful jam that contains some excellent playing by Page on the Rhodes and more lights out playing by Trey. The jam is over before we know it, and Trey kicks off “Free.” While this version doesn't break any new ground, the trend of solid playing by the band continues. “Sand” is paired nicely with “Wolfman’s Brother” next. Neither song will make anyone’s top 10 list, but they are well played and full of energy. The set closes with a standard version of “Cavern,” complete with flubbed lyrics by Trey.

Set break affords me some time to gather my thoughts, grab a fresh drink, and pay some much needed attention to my puppy dog, who hasn’t been able to figure out why I’m staring intently at the TV and throwing her tennis ball around the house.

© 2019 Phish (Rene Huemer)
© 2019 Phish (Rene Huemer)

Set II kicks off with a short but sweet “Mike’s Song,” which is then followed up by…”Fluffhead?” I have to say, of all of the songs they’ve segued into out of “Mike’s Song,” I was not expecting “Fluffhead,” but I will gladly take it. Some minor flubs aside towards the end of the song and some...interesting...singing by Fishman, “Fluffhead” is well played and the band jumps into “Twist.” At about the 12 minute mark, we segue into “Weekapaug Groove” and then almost immediately segue into “No Men In No Man’s Land” and then almost immediately after that segue back into "Weekapaug Groove" before finally winding up back in “Twist.” Both "Weekapaug Groove" and "NMINML" probably set their respective records for shortest versions played, but it was a fun little segment that’s worth checking out.

In honor of Father’s Day, the band starts up “Fuego” while providing a little extra oomph to the lyrics “World’s Greatest Dad.” “Fuego” holds a special place in my heart, as it was the favorite Phish song of a dear friend who died of cancer several years ago, and every time I hear it I’m reminded of the smile on her face when they played it at the one show she was able to attend.

Ghost” and “Bathtub Gin” round out our set, and while they feel slightly out of place, both are well played and a fine way to end the set.

Wilson” and “First Tube” are the encore, and with that the band leaves the stage and heads for north of the border. A wonderful end to a spectacular show.

So overall I thought this was a wonderful show. Sure, the song selection isn’t going to blow you away, and there were no epic jams to speak of, but considering the venue and the place in the tour, I thought the playing was top notch. I’ve got six (6) more shows on the calendar for this summer, and I cannot wait to see how the rest of the tour turns out!

I want to end this recap with a thank you to everyone. Thanks to the gracious folks at Phish.net for allowing me the opportunity to recap this show for you, thank you to The Mockingbird Foundation for continuing to donate to music programs across the country and most importantly, thank you to all of you. Every day there are articles in the news about horrible things happening throughout this world, and I’m so thankful to be part of a community of awesome and welcoming people such as yourselves. I’ve met so many wonderful people at Phish shows throughout the years, and I look forward to meeting many more of you on the road this summer and beyond. Godspeed, you crazy kids.

© 2019 Phish (Rene Huemer)
© 2019 Phish (Rene Huemer)

If you liked this blog post, one way you could "like" it is to make a donation to The Mockingbird Foundation, the sponsor of Phish.net. Support music education for children, and you just might change the world.


Comments

, comment by Slewfoot
Slewfoot Nicely done and I agree all around! A great show that is still making me smile.
, comment by tabjabber
tabjabber I was there right up front and can confirm the band (especially Trey) we’re feeding off the good energy and the festival atmosphere. He really looked happy to be there.
, comment by vreeland_t
vreeland_t Giggling. I distinctly heard Trey giggle, several times, during the broadcast. They were having fun, and pulled me along for the ride. I'm so excited by how this tour is starting out.
, comment by slowmango
slowmango Listened to this one at home - thought it was absolutely excellent. Really awesome jam out of Wolfmans and I especially like DDHVL. The Twist jam is stellar and agreed with the segue fun. So far this appears to be the best show of tour. I still have trouble with Trey's heavy tone, especially on some of the 1.0 tunes but it ends up really paying off with their jam style. The four are clearly locked in and the jamming is much more egalitarian than in previous eras. Diggin it.
, comment by blombekr
blombekr Nice review! But that Twist deserves some more ink here, eh??
, comment by bobo697
bobo697 What kind of review is this? You basically list the setlist with a few descriptors for each song. There was so much energy to this performance that you didn't even touch on. No mention of the amazing but brief type 2 in wolfmans? No mention of Trey calling out an audience half his age for being tired, and proceeding to melt their faces? No mention of him literally hammering the strings during Wilson? I mean when does he ever do that? It was Trey Van Halen. No mention of him strutting around the stage with his wireless setup like he owned the place during first tube?

What do you mean 'song selection isn't going to blow you away'?!?!? A majority of the show was fan favorite songs, with 13 songs from 1.0 alone.

These reviews should be done by people who can actually paint what it was like to be there, not just list the songs and and some descriptions.

Not hating. Just an observation. This show was much stronger in context than you gave it credit for.
, comment by imdano
imdano @bobo697 said:
What kind of review is this? You basically list the setlist with a few descriptors for each song. There was so much energy to this performance that you didn't even touch on. No mention of the amazing but brief type 2 in wolfmans? No mention of Trey calling out an audience half his age for being tired, and proceeding to melt their faces? No mention of him literally hammering the strings during Wilson? I mean when does he ever do that? It was Trey Van Halen. No mention of him strutting around the stage with his wireless setup like he owned the place during first tube?

What do you mean 'song selection isn't going to blow you away'?!?!? A majority of the show was fan favorite songs, with 13 songs from 1.0 alone.

These reviews should be done by people who can actually paint what it was like to be there, not just list the songs and and some descriptions.

Not hating. Just an observation. This show was much stronger in context than you gave it credit for.
Agree...very little thoughtful analysis and basically robo-thumbs upping everything. I felt that while there were some nice moments they are still ragged and haven't hit their stride.
, comment by InsectEffect
InsectEffect The Twist jam is time-distorting... incredible what the band can do with 10 minutes. Patient and purposeful, ascending to heavy cosmic prog. Doesn't "peak" but goes deep instead, which is essentially an inverse peak, earth rather than sky. Do we have a name for that?

Ghost into Gin is similarly patient, purposeful and lovely.

Also it's worth noting that the entire "Week -> No Men's -> Week -> Twist" segment unfolds over only 9 minutes, with segues so butter it's basically all a seamless flow. Earning those "-" hyphens for sure.

Not bad for a festival show. :-)
, comment by 339mike
339mike See what they did here? the polar opposite sterile jambase setlist regurge after the meh-ta play gloria expose and ensuing debacle of semi-undeserved collateral blow back which basically called out the volunteer scribe as fraudulent in his manifest.
So there we have it. Two opposite yet equally innocuous recap styles...so far
, comment by Slice
Slice The boys should play Twist every show because they’re fucking nailing it!
, comment by dreamingdreamsbrings
dreamingdreamsbrings How does one review a show for the blog, exactly?

I would have totally, and professionally, reviewed Friday's show, as I was in attendance DFC in front of the soundboard on the rail. I'm also a published writer.

But nobody asked.

Still waiting . . .
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Support Phish.net & MBIRD
Phish News
Subscribe to Phish-News for exclusive info while on tour!


Phish.net

Phish.net is a non-commercial project run by Phish fans and for Phish fans under the auspices of the all-volunteer, non-profit Mockingbird Foundation.

This project serves to compile, preserve, and protect encyclopedic information about Phish and their music.

Credits | Terms Of Use | Legal

© 1990-2019  The Mockingbird Foundation, Inc. | Hosted by End Point Corporation